Skip to main content
Sports

NFL Tiebreakers Explained: How Ties Decide Playoff Spots

NFL tiebreakers explained step by step: head-to-head, conference record, strength of victory and the coin toss, with real math on how 10-7 teams get split.

Eli Turner
November 22, 20268 min read
Share
NFL Tiebreakers Explained: How Ties Decide Playoff Spots
Table of contents

Your team wins on Thanksgiving, you finish the season 10-7, and you still watch the playoffs from the couch. Another 10-7 team gets your seat. Nobody lost a game that you didn't, and the season came down to a rule most fans only read in December.

That rule is the NFL tiebreakers list, a fixed sequence of 12 steps the league runs whenever teams finish level. Late November is when it starts to matter, because the standings tighten and every broadcast flashes a playoff picture with tiebreak notes beside it. Once you know the order, you can read that graphic yourself and see which of your team's remaining games actually count double.

Why NFL Tiebreakers Decide So Many Playoff Spots

The playoff field is small. Since the 2020 season the NFL has taken 14 teams, seven per conference: four division winners and three wild cards in each, according to the NFL and Fox Sports. Only the No. 1 seed in each conference gets a first-round bye.

With 16 teams fighting for seven spots in a conference, ties are common. A 17-game schedule produces a narrow band of records, and several teams usually cluster around 9-8 or 10-7. The tiebreaker list then decides three things at once: who wins a division, who gets a wild card, and where each team is seeded.

Seeding is not cosmetic. The No. 1 seed skips a round entirely, and division winners host at least one playoff game. A tiebreaker can be the difference between a home game in January and a road trip.

The Division Tiebreaker, Step by Step

When two teams in the same division finish level, the NFL runs this list in order. The first step that separates them ends the process, according to the league's published procedures.

  1. Head-to-head record between the two teams.
  2. Record in division games.
  3. Record in common games, meaning opponents both teams played.
  4. Record in conference games.
  5. Strength of victory in all games.
  6. Strength of schedule in all games.
  7. Combined ranking in points scored and points allowed among conference teams.
  8. The same combined ranking across the whole league.
  9. Net points in common games.
  10. Net points in all games.
  11. Net touchdowns in all games.
  12. Coin toss.

Division rivals play each other twice, so head-to-head is often a 1-1 split. That pushes the decision to division record, and then to common games. Because teams can play a different number of common opponents, the NFL compares winning percentage there, not raw wins.

How the wild card version differs

Teams from different divisions rarely play each other, so the wild card list changes the order. After head-to-head (only if they met), it goes straight to conference record. Common games come next, but only if the teams share at least four of them. Then strength of victory, strength of schedule and the scoring measures, with net points counted in conference games before all games.

That shift has a practical effect. In a wild card race, a win over a team in your own conference helps twice: once in the standings and again at step two of the tiebreak. A win over a team from the other conference only helps once.

Strength of Victory, With Real Numbers

Strength of victory (SOV) sounds abstract, but the math is plain. You add up the records of every team you beat, then work out their combined winning percentage. A win over a good team counts for more than a win over a bad one.

Here is a worked example with two 10-7 teams. Each beat 10 opponents.

  • Team A's 10 victims finished with a combined 80-90 record. That is 80 wins out of 170 games, or a .471 strength of victory.
  • Team B's 10 victims finished with a combined 88-82 record. That is 88 out of 170, or .518.

Team B wins the tiebreak, even though both teams have identical records. The gap is eight games spread across ten opponents, which is why SOV races are often settled by games your team is not even playing in.

Ties count as half a win. If a team you beat finishes 8-8-1, it adds 8.5 wins and 8.5 losses to your total. That detail shows up in real clinching scenarios, as the next example shows.

The Rams and Seahawks case

The best recent example came in the 2024 season. The Rams and Seahawks both finished 10-7 in the NFC West, and the earlier steps came out level, according to coverage in the Spokesman-Review and ESPN. The Rams had won the November meeting 26-20, and Seattle won the final-week rematch 30-25, so head-to-head was split.

The title went to the fifth step. ESPN reported that the Rams clinched by beating Arizona in Week 17 and then needing at least 3.5 combined wins from Minnesota, Buffalo, San Francisco, Cincinnati and Cleveland, the teams they had beaten. Those results came in on Sunday night, and the Rams won the division before the last week was played. Seattle's win over the Rams a week later changed nothing.

When Three or More Teams Tie

Multi-team ties follow the same idea with one extra rule that trips up most fans: only one team advances per step. As soon as a step separates one team from the group, that team takes the spot, and everyone else goes back to step one of the right format.

For a three-team wild card tie, the NFL first trims the group so only the highest-ranked team from each division remains. It then checks head-to-head, but only counts it if one team beat all the others or lost to all of them. After that, it runs the same sequence as the two-team version.

The restart matters because the group shrinks. A three-team tie can become a two-team tie, and the two-team list may reach a different answer than the three-team list would have. The NFL repeats the whole process to fill the second and third wild card spots, so one tiebreak can reshape the bracket three times.

How to Read the Playoff Picture Yourself

You do not need a simulator to follow a race. A few checks tell you most of what the graphic is hiding:

  • Look at conference record first. In a wild card race it is usually the first step that separates teams.
  • Circle the remaining conference games. These swing both the standings and the tiebreak at once.
  • Track the teams you already beat. Every win they pick up from here raises your strength of victory.
  • Ignore the coin toss. It sits at step 12, behind three separate scoring measures, so it almost never comes into play.

Other leagues settle level teams with their own versions of this list. Our explainer on the NBA Cup's format and tiebreakers shows a group-stage system where point differential sits second in line, right after head-to-head. College football is changing too, and our look at what a 24-team College Football Playoff changes covers how a bigger field affects at-large selection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the first NFL tiebreaker?

Head-to-head record comes first in every format. For a division tie it is followed by division record, then common games, then conference record. In wild card ties between teams from different divisions, conference record follows head-to-head directly.

How is strength of victory calculated in the NFL?

Add the season records of every team you beat, then divide their combined wins by their combined games. Ties count as half a win. The team whose victims have the higher winning percentage wins the tiebreak.

Does the NFL use a coin toss to break ties?

Yes, but only as the 12th and final step. Before it come strength of victory, strength of schedule, two points rankings, net points and net touchdowns, so the earlier steps almost always separate teams first.

How do NFL tiebreakers work with three teams?

The league first keeps only the top team from each division in the group. It then runs the steps in order, and as soon as one team is separated it takes the spot. The remaining teams restart at step one.

Every Game Counts Twice in December

NFL tiebreakers turn the last six weeks into two races running at once. One is the standings. The other is the quieter count of conference wins, common opponents and the records of teams you already beat. The 2024 NFC West was decided by results in games the Rams never played.

So when your team plays a conference rival this month, treat it as worth more than the scoreboard says. If you are working out which service shows those late-season games, our guide to what it now costs to watch your team breaks down the subscriptions.

Share

Written by

Eli Turner

Culture & Play

Covers entertainment, gaming, and sport for Quick Trend Insights, tracking how streaming economics and platform decisions reach the audience.

More articles

Related Articles

View all