Skip to main content
Daily Market Updates

Red Cat Stock Plunge: What Withdrawn Guidance Means

Red Cat stock fell after the drone maker pulled its $150M to $180M revenue target. Here is why withdrawn guidance hits harder than a miss, with the math.

Marcus Vance
November 17, 202610 min read
Share
Red Cat Stock Plunge: What Withdrawn Guidance Means
Table of contents

You check your portfolio before work on Tuesday and one position is down by a quarter before the opening bell. Sales had actually grown, by 22%. That is what happened to anyone holding Red Cat stock on November 17, the morning after the drone maker told investors it would no longer stand behind its full-year revenue target.

A miss hurts. A missing forecast hurts more, because it takes away the number everyone was using to value the company. If you own growth stocks, especially ones that depend on government contracts, you will see this pattern again.

This post walks through what Red Cat reported, why withdrawn guidance hits harder than a bad quarter, the simple math that showed the target was stretched months ago, and a short checklist you can run on any company's forecast.

What Red Cat Stock Investors Saw on November 16

Red Cat makes small military drones and, through its Blue Ops unit, uncrewed boats. In its third-quarter earnings release on its investor relations site, the company reported revenue of $11.8 million for the three months ended September 30. That was 22% higher than a year earlier. Revenue for the first nine months reached $47.4 million, up 227%.

Those growth rates sound fine until you look at the rest of the page. The company said it no longer expects to hit its previously announced full-year revenue target and is "withdrawing that target." It gave no fourth-quarter forecast to replace it.

Management named two causes. First, funding and contract awards moved more slowly than expected after the company reaffirmed its target in August. Second, the outcome of a defense competition called Gauntlet II, part of the Drone Dominance program, removed a source of revenue the company had counted on.

The bottom line got worse too. The quarterly net loss was $40.4 million, or 26 cents a share, compared with $16.0 million a year earlier. The operating loss widened to $43.4 million from $17.5 million. Investing.com reported that analysts had expected about $42 million in revenue and a loss of 20 cents a share, so the company missed both lines by a wide margin.

Why Withdrawn Guidance Hurts More Than a Miss

Guidance is a company's own forecast for a future period, usually revenue, earnings or margins. Analysts build their models around it. When a company says it expects $150 million to $180 million in sales, the price of the stock starts to reflect some version of that range.

There are four things a company can do with guidance, and each lands differently:

  • Raise it: the business is running ahead of plan. Stocks usually rise, sometimes even on a weak quarter.
  • Reaffirm it: no change. This sounds neutral but it is a promise, and the market holds the company to it.
  • Cut it: bad news, but with a new number. Investors can reprice the stock to the lower range and move on.
  • Withdraw it: the company cannot or will not say what comes next. There is no new floor to price against.

That last case is why a withdrawal often stings more than a cut. A cut tells you how bad things are. A withdrawal tells you management can't see far enough ahead to give a number, which leaves you to assume the worst. Uncertainty itself gets priced as risk, so buyers demand a lower price to take it on.

Red Cat also had a credibility problem. It had reaffirmed the target only three months earlier, on August 6. A forecast that holds in August and vanishes in November makes the next forecast, whenever it comes, harder to believe. Investing.com's premarket movers report reported that shares fell 25.8% before the open.

The Guidance Math Was Stretched Months Ago

You don't need a finance degree to test a forecast. You need the target, what the company has already booked, and how many months are left. Here is the test applied to Red Cat with its own numbers.

In its August 6 second-quarter release, Red Cat reported $20.2 million of revenue for the quarter, up 527%. First-half revenue was about $35.7 million. In the same release, it reaffirmed a full-year target of $150 million to $180 million.

Worked example, as of August:

  1. Low end of the target: $150 million minus $35.7 million booked equals $114.3 million needed in the second half.
  2. Spread over two quarters, that is about $57 million a quarter.
  3. The best quarter so far was $20.2 million. So the plan required each remaining quarter to run nearly three times the company's record.

Worked example, as of November:

  1. Nine-month revenue: $47.4 million.
  2. Low end of the target: $150 million minus $47.4 million equals $102.6 million needed in the fourth quarter alone.
  3. Third-quarter revenue was $11.8 million. The fourth quarter would have needed to be about 8.7 times larger.

The August version of this math did not prove the target would fail. Defense revenue can be lumpy, and one large order can land in a single quarter. But it told you the forecast depended on contracts that had not yet arrived. When a target needs a hockey stick, you are betting on timing, not on a trend.

Gross Margin and Cash Tell the Rest of the Story

Revenue was only part of the picture. Red Cat reported gross profit of $65 thousand for the quarter, down from $638 thousand a year earlier. On $11.8 million of sales, that works out to a gross margin of about 0.6%. In the second quarter, the company had reported a gross margin of 16.1%.

Gross margin is what is left of each sales dollar after the direct cost of making the product. At 0.6%, almost every dollar Red Cat collected went straight back into building drones and boats, leaving nothing to cover engineers, sales staff or rent. Growth at a near-zero margin does not shrink losses, which is why the operating loss more than doubled even as revenue rose.

The balance sheet adds context. Cash stood at $242.7 million on September 30, down from $325.6 million on June 30. That is a decline of $82.9 million in three months. The company also held $117.2 million of inventory, according to the release, which is product and parts it has paid for but not yet sold.

Here is why that matters to your read of the stock. A company with plenty of cash can wait for delayed contracts. A company burning cash fast cannot wait forever, and may need to sell new shares, which dilutes existing owners.

Red Cat's weighted share count was 152.8 million for the quarter. Any future share sale would spread the company's value across more of them.

How to Read Company Guidance Before It Bites You

You can't predict when a forecast will break. You can spot the ones that carry more risk. Run these checks the next time a company you own reaffirms a big number.

  • Compare the remaining target to the run rate. Subtract revenue already booked from the target, divide by quarters left, and compare it with the best quarter so far. A ratio above two deserves skepticism.
  • Ask who the customer is. Government buyers move on budget and procurement schedules the company cannot control. Red Cat named funding timing and customer acceptance as the uncertainty.
  • Watch margins alongside revenue. A sudden drop in gross margin, like Red Cat's fall from 16.1% to 0.6% in one quarter, can signal production problems before revenue shows them.
  • Track cash against losses. Divide cash by the quarterly drop in cash to get a rough number of quarters before the company needs more funding.
  • Size the position for the miss. If a single stock losing a third of its value in a morning would hurt you, it is too large a share of your portfolio.

That last point is a diversification question more than a stock-picking one. Say you held $5,000 of Red Cat going into the report. At the 25.8% premarket drop Investing.com reported, that stake would fall to about $3,710, a loss of roughly $1,290 before the market even opened. Spread across a 20-stock portfolio of equal weights, the same move would cost the whole portfolio about 1.3%.

Small-cap stocks like this also tend to swing harder than the market on any news. If you want to measure that tendency, our explainer on what beta says about your risk shows how to read it. For a contrast with a larger company, see how a weak forecast cut Intel's stock: Intel gave a lower number, while Red Cat gave none.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Red Cat stock drop?

Red Cat reported third-quarter revenue of $11.8 million on November 16, far short of the roughly $42 million analysts expected, according to Investing.com. It also withdrew its full-year revenue target of $150 million to $180 million and gave no fourth-quarter forecast. Investing.com reported that shares fell 25.8% in premarket trading the next day.

What does it mean when a company withdraws guidance?

It means the company no longer stands behind its own forecast and is not offering a new one. Investors lose the number they used to model future sales, so many sell first and wait for clarity. Companies usually cite visibility problems, as Red Cat did with defense funding and procurement timing.

Is withdrawing guidance worse than cutting it?

Often, yes. A cut gives investors a new range to price against, while a withdrawal leaves the downside open. It can also damage trust if the company reaffirmed the same target recently, as Red Cat did on August 6.

Should I buy a stock after it pulls its guidance?

Only after the company shows how it will get back to a credible forecast. Look for new signed orders, a recovery in gross margin, and enough cash to cover several quarters of losses. Red Cat ended September with $242.7 million in cash after a drop of $82.9 million in one quarter, so the runway question is real.

The Lesson From Red Cat's Missing Forecast

The quarter itself was not the whole problem. Revenue grew 22%. What broke was the promise attached to it, and the market reprices broken promises fast. If a target needs the next quarter to be many times larger than any quarter so far, treat it as a bet on contract timing and size your position to match.

The next test for Red Cat is simple: whether it can turn its pipeline into funded orders and give investors a number again.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Share

Written by

Marcus Vance

Business & Money

Writes on business and personal finance for Quick Trend Insights, translating markets, rates, and company strategy into what it costs or saves a household.

More articles

Related Articles

View all