Skip to main content
Entertainment

Oscar Rule Changes: What the New AI and Acting Rules Mean

Oscar rule changes for this season: actors can earn two nominations in one category, AI performers are out, and festival winners get a new route to the race.

Eli Turner
November 22, 20269 min read
Share
Oscar Rule Changes: What the New AI and Acting Rules Mean
Table of contents

Picture an actor with two great performances this year, one lead role and one smaller part. Under the old Oscar rules, a campaign team would quietly push the bigger role into the supporting race so the two would not split the vote. For this awards season, the Oscar rule changes make that trick much less necessary.

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences approved its rules for the 99th Oscars in May. They now apply to every film fighting for attention between now and the ceremony on Sunday, March 14. The changes cover AI, acting, international films and a handful of craft categories. If you are filling in a ballot, following the race, or just wondering why a film you love missed out, here is what moved and why it matters.

The Oscar Rule Changes at a Glance

The Academy publishes its full rules once a year. This set came out on May 1, and the Academy told NPR the changes respond to feedback from the global filmmaking community and aim to lower barriers to entry. Here are the ones that will shape what you see in January and March:

  • Acting: more than one nomination per actor per category is now possible.
  • AI and acting: only credited roles performed by consenting humans are eligible.
  • AI and writing: screenplays must be human-authored.
  • International Feature: six festival prizes now act as a second door into the race.
  • Casting: up to three statuettes can now be awarded, up from two.
  • Cinematography: the preliminary vote produces a fixed shortlist of 20 films, replacing a range of 10 to 20.

The eligibility window is the calendar year. A feature needs a qualifying theatrical release between January 1 and December 31, and the final deadline for general entries and Best Picture passed on November 12. That calendar is why a cinema run still matters to awards hopefuls, even for streamers, a shift we covered in Netflix bringing back the theatrical window.

Why One Actor Can Now Get Two Nominations

The old rule threw votes away. If an actor landed two performances in the top five of one category, only the higher vote getter was kept. The other was removed and the sixth place finisher moved up. Variety and The Daily Star both reported that the change is meant to curb "category fraud," where a lead role gets campaigned as supporting to avoid that split.

Variety pointed to history. Barry Fitzgerald was nominated in both lead and supporting for the same role in Going My Way at the 17th Academy Awards, and the Academy then limited each performance to one nomination. It also cited Kate Winslet, who campaigned in lead for Revolutionary Road and supporting for The Reader. The Reader was moved to lead, and she won Best Actress for it.

A worked example

Here is how the change plays out with simple, made up numbers. Imagine Best Actress nominations voting ends with these six performances ranked by votes:

  1. Performer A, Film One: 410 votes
  2. Performer B, Film Two: 385 votes
  3. Performer C, Film Three: 350 votes
  4. Performer B, Film Four: 320 votes
  5. Performer D, Film Five: 300 votes
  6. Performer E, Film Six: 295 votes

Under the old rule, Performer B's second entry (320 votes) is struck off, and Performer E gets in with 295. Under the new rule, Performer B takes two of the five slots and Performer E misses out. The cutoff for a nomination effectively rises from 295 votes to 300.

NPR used Anne Hathaway, who has five major releases this year, as a hypothetical. Deadline's Pete Hammond told NPR an actor could even take three of five slots: "Probably won't happen, but it's now possible." For you as a viewer, the practical effect is simple. A performer having a huge year can now be rewarded for all of it, instead of the campaign choosing one role for you.

What the Human-Only Rules Mean for AI

This is the change with the longest reach. Acting eligibility now requires a role that is credited in the film's legal billing and "demonstrably performed by humans with their consent," according to the Academy's announcement. Writing categories now require a human-authored screenplay. Artificial intelligence can still be used as a tool, but the Academy reserved the right to ask filmmakers how they used generative AI and how much of the work was human.

The rule closes a door that some people were already trying to open. NPR noted that Tilly Norwood, an AI-generated performer created by the studio Particle6, had posted "Can't wait to go to the Oscars!" in March. Under these rules, a synthetic performer cannot realistically win an acting award.

How this builds on last year: For the 98th Oscars, the Academy said AI tools would neither help nor harm a film's chances, and that it would judge the human creative work. This year turns that stance into hard eligibility rules for actors and writers.

The word "consent" carries a lot of weight here. It means a digital recreation of a real actor, built without permission, is not eligible either. Music is having the same fight from the other side, as we described in AI music being sued and licensed at once. Film's biggest awards body has now drawn its line at the human performance.

The International Feature Race Gets a Second Door

Countries used to own the nomination. Each submitted one film, and if a national committee picked something else, the most celebrated film from that country could be shut out. NPR described the new approach as shifting the honour from countries to filmmakers.

The case everyone cites is Anatomy of a Fall. It won the Palme d'Or at Cannes, but France submitted The Taste of Things instead, The Daily Star recalled. The Taste of Things was not nominated. Anatomy of a Fall went on to earn five nominations including Best Picture, and won Original Screenplay. The Daily Star noted that some now call the change the "Anatomy of a Fall rule."

The six festival prizes that now qualify

A non-English film can enter by winning one of these awards, according to the Academy:

  • Berlin International Film Festival: Golden Bear
  • Busan International Film Festival: Busan Award for Best Film
  • Cannes Film Festival: Palme d'Or
  • Sundance Film Festival: World Cinema Grand Jury Prize
  • Toronto International Film Festival: Platform Award
  • Venice International Film Festival: Golden Lion

The nominee is now the film itself, not the country. The director accepts on behalf of the creative team, and their name goes on the plaque after the film's title. Onmanorama pointed out that this matters in countries such as India, where several strong films often compete for one submission slot.

Smaller Changes That Still Shape the Ballot

Some changes only touch one branch, but they decide who gets to vote and what they must watch first. The Academy keeps adding viewing requirements, and that tends to help smaller films that voters might otherwise skip.

  • Visual Effects: every member must watch the three-minute Before and After reels from the bake-off to vote in the final round.
  • Makeup and Hairstyling: branch members must attend at least one of two final roundtables to vote in the preliminary round.
  • Original Song: a song placed as the first new music cue in the end credits must be submitted with the last 15 seconds of the film before the credits.
  • Governors Awards: each year's honorees must represent at least three disciplines.
  • Campaigning: screenings with a Q&A before nominations can now have two moderators instead of one.

These sit on top of last year's big one: members must watch every nominated film in a category to vote in that category's final round. If you have ever wondered why Grammy voting and the Oscars feel so different, rules like these are a large part of the answer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an actor be nominated twice in the same Oscar category?

Yes, starting with the 99th Oscars. If two of an actor's performances both finish in the top five of the same category, both are nominated. Before, only the higher ranked one counted.

Can an AI actor win an Oscar?

No. Acting awards now require a role credited in the film's legal billing and performed by a human who consented. Screenplays must also be human-authored, though AI can still be used as a supporting tool.

When are the next Oscars?

The 99th Academy Awards are scheduled for Sunday, March 14, airing live at 7 p.m. ET on ABC from the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood. Films must have opened in cinemas between January 1 and December 31 of this year to qualify.

How many films can one country send to the Oscars now?

Each country still picks one official submission. Other non-English films from the same country can now qualify by winning a top prize at Berlin, Busan, Cannes, Sundance, Toronto or Venice.

What to Watch for Before March

The Oscar rule changes do three things. They stop the Academy from throwing away votes for actors with two big roles. They put a hard human line around acting and writing. And they let festival juries open a door that national committees used to control.

Watch the supporting categories closely when nominations land. If a campaign still moves a lead role down a category this year, it is now a choice, not a necessity. That alone will tell you a lot about how studios think the race is shaping up.

Share

Written by

Eli Turner

Culture & Play

Covers entertainment, gaming, and sport for Quick Trend Insights, tracking how streaming economics and platform decisions reach the audience.

More articles

Related Articles

View all