Skip to main content
Entertainment

Grammy Voting: How Winners Are Actually Chosen

Grammy voting runs in two rounds with strict ballot limits. See who votes, why records miss the cutoff, and how 100 categories shrink to one winner each.

Eli Turner
November 22, 20269 min read
Share
Grammy Voting: How Winners Are Actually Chosen
Table of contents

Your favorite album came out in early September, topped the charts and soundtracked your whole autumn. Then the Grammy nominations dropped on November 16 and it was nowhere on the list. No snub happened. Grammy voting runs on a calendar most fans never see, and that record simply missed the cutoff by a few days.

Most people picture a panel of judges arguing in a room. The real system is a two-round ballot cast by thousands of working musicians, producers and engineers, with hard limits on what each one can vote for. Once you see how it works, the nominations make a lot more sense, and you can read the February 7 results with a sharper eye.

Here is how Grammy voting actually picks a winner, from the first entry to the final count.

The Grammy Calendar Starts a Year Before the Show

The Recording Academy set this cycle's eligibility window from August 31 to August 28, spanning almost a full year. A song or album had to be released in that stretch, and stay publicly available until final voting ends, to compete at the 69th Grammy Awards.

Labels, distributors and Academy members then had to enter it. According to the Recording Academy's own submission guide, the online entry period ran from July 7 to August 21, with only one round. That means even late-August releases had to be entered before they came out.

Why your favorite record might be missing

Here is a worked example. Say an album came out on September 4. It missed the August 28 cutoff by one week, so it falls into the next cycle. Its nominations will be announced around next November, and it will compete in a ceremony roughly 17 months after release day.

That gap explains a lot of apparent snubs. It also explains how an old song can compete: The Fader and TheGrio both reported that "Morning Dew (Donk)," a long-unreleased vault track Beyoncé put out as a single, earned her a 100th career nomination. No artist had reached that mark before.

Who Actually Votes for the Grammys

Only Voting Members of the Recording Academy cast ballots. These are people with credits on commercially released music: performers, songwriters, producers, engineers and others. Professional Members, student members and the record companies that submit entries cannot vote at all.

The Academy also asks voters to stick to their lane. Its official voting guide tells members to vote only where they are a peer, so a jazz bassist is not supposed to decide the best Latin rock album. The awards are meant to reflect what each genre's own community respects.

The 10 and 3 rule

On the standard ballot, a member can vote in up to 10 categories spread across no more than three genre fields. On top of that, everyone can vote in the six General Field categories:

  • Record of the Year
  • Album of the Year
  • Song of the Year
  • Best New Artist
  • Producer of the Year, Non-Classical
  • Songwriter of the Year, Non-Classical

So the maximum is 16 categories out of 100. A typical voter skips more than four in five of them. This cycle added an option called Ballot Plus. Members whose verified credits span several genres can opt in and vote in up to 15 peer categories in any field, which raises their ceiling to 21.

Round One Builds the Nominee List

First round voting ran from October 12 to October 22. Before that, Academy staff screened every entry for eligibility and checked that it sat in the right category. The Academy says it can receive more than 20,000 eligible entries in a single season, which is why screening comes first.

Voters then listened through the entries in their chosen categories and marked their picks. The independent accounting firm Deloitte collects and counts the ballots, so the Academy itself does not tally votes.

The top vote getters become nominees. In the four biggest categories, the top eight finishers make the list. In all 96 other categories, including the producer and songwriter awards in the General Field, the top five do.

Round Two Picks the Winners

Final round voting runs from December 10 to January 7. The same pool of Voting Members returns, this time choosing one winner from each shortlist. Deloitte counts again, and results stay sealed until the envelopes open on February 7.

This round is where campaigns matter most. Labels spend the holiday stretch running listening events and ads aimed squarely at Academy voters. That is a tiny audience compared with the millions who stream the nominees, which is why Grammy winners do not always match the year's biggest hits.

Why big streams do not guarantee a win

Chart success and Grammy success measure different things. Billboard counts what the public plays, and it keeps adjusting how streams count, as covered in our piece on Billboard counting YouTube streams again. Grammy voters are asked to judge only artistic and technical merit. A modest seller with brilliant production can beat a streaming giant.

What Changed in Grammy Voting This Cycle

The Academy changed several rules before this round. Billboard, Hypebot and Stereogum all reported the same core list, and the shifts show up in the nominations.

  • Five new categories, bringing the total to 100: Best Asian Pop Music Performance, Best R&B Collaboration or Duo/Group Performance, Best Traditional Pop Vocal Performance, Best Traditional Folk Album and Best Latin Song.
  • Album rule loosened. An album now needs 66% newly recorded material to qualify, down from 75%.
  • Best New Artist window widened. An artist can now be entered up to four times, up from three.
  • Ballot Plus, the multi-genre voting option described above.

How the album rule plays out in real numbers

Take a 12-track album. Under the old 75% rule, 9 of those tracks had to be new recordings. Under the new 66% rule, the math is 12 times 0.66, which is 7.92, so 8 new tracks clear the bar. That one track of room matters for deluxe editions, live cuts and re-recorded versions that used to get disqualified.

The Best Latin Song category also carries its own test: a song needs at least 51% Spanish lyrics. The new Asian pop category drew attention for a different reason. Several outlets reported that BTS chose not to submit this cycle, which some fans read as a protest against being moved into a genre box.

Reading This Year's Nominations

With the mechanics in hand, the leaderboard tells a clearer story. Raye leads with 11 nominations, including Record and Album of the Year, according to ABC News and CBS News. Rosalía follows with nine. Ella Langley, Miranda Lambert, Olivia Rodrigo and Phoebe Bridgers have seven each.

Album of the Year has eight nominees, as the top eight rule requires. They include Raye, Rosalía, Olivia Rodrigo, Olivia Dean, Bruno Mars, Phoebe Bridgers, Ella Langley and Taylor Swift. Big numbers like Raye's tend to come from crossover appeal: a record that pleases voters in pop, R&B and songwriting can rack up nods in several fields at once.

Still, nomination counts are a weak guide to wins. Each category is a separate vote by a different slice of members, so a leader can go home with two trophies while a single nominee takes the night's top prize.

A New Home for the Ceremony

The 69th Grammy Awards air live on Sunday, February 7, from Crypto.com Arena in Los Angeles. For the first time in more than half a century, the show is not on CBS. Disney won the rights in a 10-year deal announced by the Recording Academy and Disney, so the ceremony now airs on ABC and streams on Disney+ and Hulu.

That move matters beyond the remote control. Disney also holds the Oscars, so ABC carries both of music and film's biggest award nights this winter. Expect heavier promotion and more Grammy specials across Disney's apps between now and February.

Frequently Asked Questions

How are Grammy winners chosen?

Voting Members of the Recording Academy pick winners in a final round of voting held from December 10 to January 7. Each member votes in the six General Field categories plus a limited set of genre categories where they have expertise. The accounting firm Deloitte counts the ballots.

Can the public vote for the Grammys?

No. Only Recording Academy Voting Members, who hold credits on commercially released music, can vote. Fan polls and streaming numbers play no direct part in nominations or wins.

What is the eligibility period for the next Grammys?

This ceremony covered releases from August 31 to August 28 of the following year. Music released after the August cutoff competes in the following cycle, and the Recording Academy publishes the exact new dates on its site each year.

How many categories are there at the Grammys now?

There are 100 categories after the Academy added five new ones this cycle, including Best Asian Pop Music Performance and Best Latin Song.

Why do Grammy winners differ from the most streamed songs?

Voters are working music professionals asked to judge artistic and technical merit, not popularity. A body of working peers can reach a very different verdict from millions of listeners. If you follow how technology is reshaping that tension, our look at how AI music is being sued and licensed at once covers the next fight.

What to Watch for Before February 7

Grammy voting is less mysterious than it looks. Entries close in August, peers narrow 100 categories to shortlists in October, and the same peers pick winners over the holidays. The eligibility window explains most snubs, and the peer ballot explains most surprises.

If you like comparing how award bodies work, the video game world runs a very different jury model, which we broke down in our guide to how Game of the Year is picked. For the Grammys, mark January 7 as the day the ballots lock. After that, nothing a label spends can change the result.

Share

Written by

Eli Turner

Culture & Play

Covers entertainment, gaming, and sport for Quick Trend Insights, tracking how streaming economics and platform decisions reach the audience.

More articles

Related Articles

View all